An article from The Mid Sussex Times, Tuesday June 9 1891, modernised for twenty first century readers

Serious Assault in Cuckfield – Soldier Charged

A disturbing case of assault came before the magistrates this week, involving Ernest Neale, a private in the 14th Hussars, and Alfred Rice, a fishmonger’s assistant. The two men were accused of attacking Walter Gilbert, a carter, and his wife near Moonhill Farm, Cuckfield, on the evening of May 19th.

Mr. J. C. Buckwell appeared for Rice, while Mr. A. V. Treacher represented Neale. The court heard that compensation had been accepted for the injuries sustained, but as the offence was a serious misdemeanour, the prosecution proceeded.

The Incident

Walter Gilbert testified that around 9.30pm he and his wife were walking home when they encountered two soldiers and another man. As Mrs. Gilbert was climbing over a stile, one of the soldiers allegedly seized her and threw her down. When Mr. Gilbert rushed to help, he was struck on the forehead with a whip and beaten unconscious. Mrs. Gilbert was also assaulted, receiving a severe black eye. The attackers reportedly laughed as they left the scene.

Medical Evidence

Mr. Gilbert was left with two black eyes, a lacerated scalp, and a bruised face. He was confined to bed for several days and unable to work for a fortnight. His wife also suffered visible injuries.

Witness Accounts

Several witnesses recalled seeing the soldiers and the Gilberts earlier that evening at local public houses, including the White Hart and the Wheatsheaf. It was noted that Neale appeared intoxicated, while Rice was said to be sober.

Harriet Gilbert, wife of the complainant, corroborated her husband’s account, identifying Neale and Rice as their assailants. Other witnesses, including local farmer John Lawrence and medical practitioner Richard Fitzmaurice, confirmed the extent of the injuries.

Defence & Examination

Neale denied striking Mrs. Gilbert or using foul language, admitting only to a scuffle with Mr. Gilbert, whom he claimed had struck first. Rice maintained he had no involvement in the violence, insisting he had been present but not engaged.

Outcome

After deliberation, the Bench decided Neale should be committed for trial at the Quarter Sessions on June 30th, bail being allowed – himself in £50 and two sureties of £25 each. Rice was dismissed from the charge.

Summary: A violent altercation in Cuckfield involving two soldiers left a local carter and his wife badly beaten. While conflicting accounts were given, Ernest Neale now faces trial, accused of serious assault. Alfred Rice, however, has been discharged.